The All-Upper Michigan Swimming and Diving Team selections were begun in 1996.
| Year | Name | Event |
|---|---|---|
| 1998 | Shelly Ruspakka | Swimming |
| Terri Campbell (Honorable Mention) | Swimming | |
| 1997 | Michelle Bennon | Swimming |
| Terri Campbell | Swimming | |
| Erica Nurmela | Swimming | |
| 1996 | Michelle Wallace | Diving |
| Michelle Bennon | Swimming |